How to Deal with Bad Airbnb Guests

Most Airbnb guests are respectful and a pleasure to host. However, even the most experienced Airbnb property managers will eventually encounter a few bad guests. From ignored house rules to property damage, inappropriate guest behavior or disruptive extra guests, knowing how to address such situations is crucial to running a successful short-term rental business.

In this article, we’ll walk you through strategies for identifying, managing and preventing bad guests on Airbnb and other booking platforms — so you can maintain your reputation, protect your listing and deliver a consistently positive experience to all your future guests.

The Cost of Difficult Guests

Difficult guests can cost you time, money and peace of mind. They may break house rules, disturb other guests, refuse to follow your check-out process or leave an unfairly negative review that affects your ranking. Some cause property damage or attempt to game the system.

Even one incident can lead to bad reviews which deter potential new guests. Proactively managing and preventing such incidents isn’t just advisable — it’s necessary to prevent future issues.

Strategies to Prevent and Address Airbnb Guests Who Behave Badly

There are two key strategies for handling problematic occupants in short-term rentals. First, focus on prevention: Screen potential guests carefully and then, set clear expectations upfront to discourage unwanted behavior. Second, if issues still arise, address them professionally and promptly to minimize disruption and damage to your vacation rental property.

How to prevent bad guests

1. Screen travelers carefully

A solid screening process is your first and most effective defense against bad guests. Screening allows you to evaluate a traveler's profile, evaluate their prior stays and assess the likelihood of problematic behavior.

How to screen Airbnb guests

• Check their reviews: Always read past guest reviews from other hosts to spot patterns of disrespect or bad behavior.

• Review their profile: Incomplete or vague profiles, or those lacking verification, are warning signs.

• Ask questions: Engage before booking to gauge the guest’s tone, reason for travel and expectations.

• Use Instant Book selectively: Set conditions like verified ID, a completed profile and good reviews.

• Use automated screening tools: Automated solutions can surface red flags before the reservation is confirmed.

Automated guest screening tools for Airbnb hosts

Hostaway integrates with several professional tools for automated screening:

• Autohost Automates background checks and screens for risks like chargeback fraud or criminal history. Helps detect bad problematic travelers before check-in.

• Safely Formerly SafelyStay, this tool checks for international watchlists, criminal history and offers liability insurance coverage.

• ChargeAutomation Helps automate security deposits, ID verification and pre-arrival forms. Reduces fraud and streamlines compliance with your vacation rental rules.

• Authenticate Provides advanced identity and optional facial recognition. Helps confirm the traveler’s identity and reduce booking risk.

• Trustd.ai Uses behavioral analytics and machine learning to assess booking risk and identify potentially difficult guests before confirmation.

Using automated tools to screen travelers allows Airbnb property managers to make informed decisions, deter unwanted behavior and protect their short-term rental operations.

2. Write and enforce house rules

Your house rules are your contract with the guest. The clearer your rules, the easier they are to enforce and refer to in disputes.

Essential rules to include:

• List clear rules on noise levels, occupancy, pets and check-in/check-out times and procedures.

• Include the rules in your Airbnb listing and display it inside the property. Including it as part of a guidebook is a great way to get the message across without coming across as being aggressive

• Include rule reminders in pre-arrival messages.

• Highlight important rules like party bans and occupancy limits.

• Expectations for cleanliness and communication

Sticking to clear rules and enforcement shows travelers you take your role as a professional property manager seriously.

3. Set clear expectations from the start

Setting clear expectations via good communication helps deter guests with questionable intentions. The way you communicate also sets the tone for the guest’s stay.

• Include rules and policies clearly in your listing.

• Send a welcome message reiterating check-in times, quiet hours and important rules.

• Provide a digital or printed welcome guide.

• Reaffirm rules during the stay via scheduled messages.

When expectations are clear, bad guests have fewer excuses — and good ones feel supported. It also shows you’re a proactive host.

How to deal with bad guests

1. Keep detailed records

To prepare for potential disputes, keep detailed records of every guest’s stay.

What to document:

• Booking and communication history

• Reports of noise complaints or guest complaints

• Time-stamped photos and videos of damages or violations

• Written notes from neighbors or cleaners

When it’s time to escalate to Airbnb, these records will help support your case.

2. Use noise-monitoring devices (legally)

These devices can help detect parties, unauthorized extra guests and unsafe behavior. While indoor cameras are banned by Airbnb, it’s legal (in many jurisdictions) to use decibel meters and exterior surveillance — so long as you follow local regulations and disclose them in your listing.

Monitoring noise can help prevent bad reviews, property damage and neighbor complaints. Noise-monitoring tools like Minut and NoiseAware integrate seamlessly with Hostaway.

Just make sure to:

• Follow local laws

• Disclose use in your Airbnb listing

Integrating such devices helps identify difficult guests before neighbors file complaints.

3. Know when to contact Airbnb

If your guest's behavior violates Airbnb's terms or results in damage, it's time to contact Airbnb.

When to escalate to Airbnb:

• The guest breaks significant house rules

• There’s confirmed theft or serious property damage

• There’s harassment or threats

• The guest complains excessively or unreasonably

Report issues within 72 hours. Use the Airbnb Resolution Center and include all relevant documentation.

4. Collect a damage deposit

A deposit reinforces your rules and makes occupants think twice before causing trouble. Platforms like Airbnb allow taking damage deposits when using a property management software like Hostaway.

Best practices for collecting a damage deposit:

• Outline deposit terms in your listing

• Document property condition before and after the guest’s stay

• Collect via secure channels or partners

This safeguard another layer of protection for Airbnb hosts and is especially useful for newer Airbnb guests without an established stay history.

5. Leave honest guest reviews

Don’t skip this step. Your reviews of guests not only help other Airbnb hosts, but also protect the platform’s community by identifying bad guests.

When reviewing a guest:

• Stick to the facts

• Mention rule violations or bad behavior

• Avoid emotional or accusatory language

• Don’t exaggerate or understate

Reviews also reward great guests and encourage positive experience sharing. Remember, they shape your hosting future.

6. Offer solutions before a conflict escalates

Sometimes, you can offer solutions that resolve concerns before they become serious.

For example:

• Address noise before it turns into a noise complaint

• Clarify check-in times when there’s confusion

• Politely remind the guest of your rules when they're bending them

Many difficult guests improve with the right feedback, and you'll avoid low ratings and foster goodwill.

7. Manage repeat offenders

You don’t have to host the same bad guests twice. If the same person tries to book again and caused issues before, you can deny the booking request. Block specific users and flag the account internally.

This is especially important for Airbnb travelers who left bad reviews unfairly or damaged your short-term rental property.

8. Build a trusted community

As you host more Airbnb guests, you’ll start to identify common traits of both reliable and risky travelers. Leverage this insight.

• Encourage good reviews from excellent guests

• Add preferred travelers to your mailing list

• Use CRM tools like Hostaway's to manage your guest’s identity and preferences

This keeps your calendar full of guests who treat your vacation rental with care and minimize your exposure to troublemakers.

Red Flags to Watch for Before Accepting a Reservation

No matter how experienced you are as a host, spotting warning signs early is critical to avoiding bad guests. Subtle red flags in a guest's profile or messages can indicate a higher risk of issues during the guest’s stay.

Here are some common red flags to look out for before deciding to confirm a reservation:

1. Incomplete or suspicious profiles

If a traveler's profile lacks a photo, description or verification, it’s a signal to dig deeper. While new travelers without a stay history aren’t always a risk, the absence of basic details makes it harder to trust the booking.

Tip: Use completed profile, verified ID and past positive reviews to help qualify new bookers.

2. Avoidance of communication

When potential guests avoid answering basic questions or seem evasive about the purpose of their trip, it’s often a sign they’re hiding something. This type of behavior has frequently been linked with bad guests trying to avoid scrutiny.

Tip: Ask about arrival time, group size and what they’re looking for in their stay. Their tone and willingness to engage can reveal a lot.

3. Requests that violate house rules

If someone requests early check-in, to bring additional guests or to host a “quiet gathering,” they may be signaling a disregard for your rules before even arriving.

Tip: Stay firm and politely restate your rules. If they continue pushing boundaries before booking, it may be best to decline.

4. Previous negative reviews

Always read previous reviews from other hosts. Even just one or two negative reviews may indicate a pattern of problematic behavior, such as ignoring instructions, causing disturbances or leaving the property in poor condition.

Tip: Look for phrases like “would not host again,” “disrespectful,” or “didn’t follow instructions” — these are clear red flags.

Identifying red flags helps prevent future issues and protects your short-term rental. While everyone deserves a chance, it’s your responsibility as a host to create a safe and respectful environment for all Airbnb guests.

By being alert to potential warning signs and combining them with the right tools, you’ll reduce your risk of hosting bad guests and enjoy smoother, more profitable hosting experiences.

Minimize Risk, Maximize Peace of Mind

Dealing with bad Airbnb guests is inevitable, but with preparation, it’s manageable. With strong guest screening, firm rules and proactive communication, you can minimize your exposure to bad guests and protect your business.

By using tools and techniques like automated screening, proactive messaging, damage deposit collection and noise monitoring devices, you can better manage difficult guests, reduce risks and improve your hosting outcomes.